Today the British Board of Film Classification (BBFC) issued its long-awaited consultation document in which it sets out its thoughts and proposals in relation to those parts of the Digital Economy Act, 2017 that require commercial pornography web sites to introduce age verification.
Readers will note that the final, formal, step whereby the BBFC became the legally designated regulator was not actually completed until 21st February so I think they have done remarkably well to get this ready and out in such a comparatively short space of time.
I’m guessing the BBFC will be acutely aware that forces who are still opposed to the measure will be looking for even the tiniest procedural slip up to allow them to jump in and disrupt, halt, discredit or delay the process. They lost the argument but they won’t have abandoned any hope of killing off the idea in some other way. We should not help them achieve that ambition. Better to be safe than sorry.
Comments on either or both are invited by 23rd April.
I won’t try to summarise the papers here because, having the read the documents, they appear to me to be clearly written and succinctly presented.
I would make just two obvious points: the BBFC’s main role in this area is narrow and limited. It is required to determine whether or not a website qualifies under the Act and, if it does, whether or not it has in place a solution that means children cannot ordinarily access its content. If, after notice, a site remains non-compliant certain things may follow.
However, the privacy dimension of any age verification solution is the primary responsibility of the UK’s data protection authority, otherwise known as the Information Commissioner’s Office.
Having said that, the BBFC does point out that there is a key privacy issue at play here and that is the principle of data minimization. In other words porn sites do not need to know your name, address, credit card number or indeed anything other than whether or not you have been reliably verified as being 18 or above.
If, as seems likely, some porn providers also offer an age verification service that is associated with a company they own or control, unless they also allow and accept alternative solutions they run the risk of attracting legal challenges on the ground of unfair commercial practices and they will also need to be able to show there is an impenetrable curtain separating the affairs of both enterprises.